Saturday, June 15, 2013

Nigerian CSOs kick against FG’s multi-million contracts on Internet surveillance



A coalition of 11 civil society organizations (CSO) working on Information and Communication Technology (ICT) for Development in Nigeria has call on the Federal Government to respect Internet Freedom and Privacy of Citizens by stopping any attempt to scrutinize the Internet access of Nigerians, describing it a rude, undemocratic and illegal violation of the privacy of citizens.

DigitalSENSE Business News recalls that media was recently awash that the Nigerian government had signed a $40 Million contract with an Israel-based company, Elbit Systems, to monitor internet communication in Nigeria, while another report has it that FG has set aside $61.9 Million for ‘Wise Intelligence Network Harvest Analyzer System’, Open Source Internet Monitoring System, Personal Internet Surveillance System And Purchase Of Encrypted Communication Equipment.”

The coalition is made up of Budgit, Centre for Information Technology Awareness and Development, Co-Creation Hub, Development Information Network, Enough-is-Enough Nigeria, Fantsuam Foundation, Media Rights Agenda, Paradigm Initiative Nigeria, Wennovation Hub, West African NGONetwork and Women’s Technology Empowerment Centre.

The group in a press statement made available to DigitalSENSE Business News weekend acknowledged the importance of Internet as a platform for governance, education, commerce, and indeed for all social engagements, saying that the surveillance attempt on the Internet in Nigeria could take the nation many years back into the military era, when surveillance became a tool of oppression by the State.

They also outlined five points to buttress their position including that the government must protect the privacy of all citizens and this should not be violated through such unwarranted surveillance of all technology-mediated communication; such as communication with friends and loved ones by email, Short Messaging Service (SMS) and chat.

Equally, the coalition said its huge waste of public resources with absolutely no return on investment because as an open platform, the Internet has a reasonable amount of safeguards against criminal uses. In addition, the current legal instruments – if effectively employed – provide for adequate non-intrusive surveillance of suspected criminals.

They further describe the contracts as monumental waste of efforts in addressing security challenges because criminals who use the Internet for criminal purposes usually deploy sophisticated encryption technologies for which the surveillance of mail reading and interception of other communications would disproportionately affect the average and less technically-sophisticated citizen.


According to the group, the contract is a total negation of the local content principle that the government through the National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA) has been promoting and which is necessary for the repositioning of the national economy to achieve the goals of Vision 20:2020.

Additionally, they told DigitalSENSE Business News that if government is interested in fighting cyber crime, it would focus attention on legislating specific and better targeted cybercrime-related laws that have been waiting for government action at various stages.

Insisting that this measure by FG is a flagrant violation of the constitutional guarantee of the privacy of citizens as provided for in Section 37 of the 1999 Constitution, which stipulates in very clear terms that “The privacy of citizens, their homes, correspondence, telephone conversations and telegraphic communications is hereby guaranteed and protected.”

The group pointed out that only permissible circumstances under which this right may be restricted are those stated in Section 45(1) of the Constitution, which means that the measure taken must be in accordance with a “law that is reasonably justifiable in a democratic society” to protect the stated interests or the rights and freedoms of other persons.


... Making SENSE of digital revolution!

No comments: