Monday, March 4, 2013

2.3GHz operators insist licensing new operator is anti-competition


The three licensees on the 2.3 Gega Hertz (GHz) in Nigeria have said that licensing new operator based on proposed plan by the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) is anti-competition.


Lolia Emorpkore with Executive Commissioner Stakeholder Engagement Okey Itanyi
and Head Spectrum at NCC Austin Nwawunne
These operators are namely Mobitel, Direct-On Pc and SpectraNet and made their position known at the one-day stakeholders’ forum on 2.3GHz band organized by NCC with the theme: Best Option for Licensing the remaining slots in the 2.3GH band.

Speaking on behalf of the trio in a joint paper presented by the chief operating officer of SpectraNet, Mr. Atul Ojha, at the forum, they objected to licensing new operator on this band with 30 Mega Hertz (MHz), while the existing operators wallow in 20 MHz.

They also described the proposed plan as not advisable for enthronement of competitive market.

The paper entitled ‘Operators View Point on 2.3GHz Spectrum Allocations and Challenges’ they also said that in their views “fresh auction of 30 MHz is not advisable.”

They postulated that using 10 MHz to provide for 5 Guard bands has no meaning as each Guard band would be 2 MHz, adding that end of 2.3 GHz band would require larger Guard band due to uncontrolled emissions in 2.4 GHz.

In addition, they argued that globally wireline networks provide primary network reach and wireless as secondary reach, lamenting that in Nigeria, no significant primary wireline network exist, and hence, wireless becomes the primary network with extra capacity requirement.

“In Nigeria, to roll out advance Wireless Network larger spectrum is basic need,” they pointed out.

They maintained that by increasing the number of operators in last mile access network, that is 2.3GHz, would not enhance the data penetration, unless other dominant cost head are addressed or else last mile operator failure remains inevitable.

For the chief executive officer, Mobitel, Mr. Johnson Salako, told DigitalSENSE Business News all they were asking for is a level playing ground to enable existing operators on that band to survive, adding that its unfair for existing operators to have 20 MHz while the new one now has 30 MHz, hence such proposition is ill-advised.

In his welcome remark, the Head, Spectrum Management at NCC, Engr. Augustine Nwawunne, said the essence is truly engage stakeholders on the way forward devoid of technicalities and urged participants to open the floor for better discussions.

In his keynote to the occasion, the Executive Vice Chairman (EVC), NCC, Dr. Eugene Juwah, who was represented by the Executive Commissioner, Stakeholders Engagement, Hon. Okey Itanyi, said the objective of the forum was in line with the Commission’s policy of participatory regulation amongst other things to provide an avenue for stakeholders and users of the 2.3 GHz band to discuss, technically criticize, exchange ideas and proffer options that will help the Commission in arriving at a decision on the further licensing of the remaining 40 MHz bandwidth in the band for the benefit of all Nigerians.

“This forum is very remarkable as we have in our midst highly respected presenters with decades of practical experience at their disposal to deliberate on options and challenges as it relates to further licensing of the band,” he said.
Austin from NCC speaking, while Mr Atul Ojha behind ready for the forum. Photo DSBN

With global development centred on availability of broadband services, the Commission, he said, is on a regular basis inundated with several requests for frequencies to deliver the services.

“This has posed severe challenges as the frequencies sought for are scarce,” he said,

According to him, in no distant future, the industry predicts the development and indeed deployment of more spectral efficient technologies that would be able to deliver more with less frequency spectrum.

Also, he said that improvement on interference mitigation techniques would pave way for a harmonious and interference free coexistence, as they look forward to being part of the future in the management and utilization of this resource in line with global best practices.

Remmy Nweke/DSBNews
... Making SENSE of digital revolution!

No comments: