Saturday, December 1, 2012

NCC versus Operators: The big ban!


F.O.C. credit and telecom operators
Since the ban on all promotions being offered by telecommunications operators in the country by the industry regulator, the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC), divergent views have erupted for and against the bold step.
Noteworthy is that in the lifespan of this administration at NCC, there seems to have been a kind of gut display by the regulator to assert its position in the current dispensation.
Although, all the four Global System for Mobile Communication (GSM) operators and Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) counterparts were affected by the NCC ban, obviously for the regulator to recapture the activities of these operators that was quite becoming unbecoming. It must be stated that all of them may not be guilty of network congestion, so it is apt to highlight some of the offers that aided NCC action.
Investigations by DigitalSENSE Business News revealed that mostly GSM operators offer one free credit bonus on calls daily or another, which worsened the deteriorating networks since the last penalty on poor quality of service was pronounced, as the number of operators cling to five-times your recharge.
From Glo, …
Despite the network challenges that has persistent on Glo, the mobile operator within these period choose to offer free 500 per cent call bonus, which induced subscribers on the basis that they recharge and use up the daily target.
Also, Glo 500 per cent call bonus is only for on-net calls and expires by before 12am every day, thereby literally forcing subscribers struggle to use up in the name of enjoying the Glo 500 per cent call credit bonus, that is after activation by sending the world ‘bonus’ in an SMS to 4567. Incidentally, getting the bonus may not be much of headache, but using it to make the calls was an uphill task, thus making Glo to rank first among the affected operators.
For MTN …
Aware of its lead in the mobile market in Nigeria, MTN offering of five times bonus by crediting customers with 500 per cent of the individual required daily usage once a customer spend up to or exceed the daily usage. And it’s only available to pre-paid subscribers.
The bonus, it was gathered, expires at 12 midnight everyday and could only be used only for on-net calls but the assigned daily usage is based on airtime used for on-net and off-net calls with the exemption of international calls.
On MTN network, customers does not require to send a special code, it only requires customers to opt-in by dialing *507# and do the normal recharge process and the bonus is receivable once a day.
And from Airtel 5X to Etisalat daily pass:
Equally, the Airtel 5X offer gives free 500 per cent call bonus to on-net calls on using the specified daily target and expires by 12am every day. To get the 500 per cent bonus subscribers only need to activate by dialing *470#, after which the subscriber would receive a message notifying of the daily target.
Etisalat Nigeria tagged its bonus ‘1 Day pass’ offering 100 per cent bonus on usage of N100 and subscribers could get the bonus more than once on using up to N100 subsequently. While bonuses from other operators can also be use to make on-net calls, Etisalat’s 1 Day Pass bonus can be used for on-net, off-net, international calls, browse and SMS.
Juwah, Executive Vice Chairman, NCC
Therefore, these free credits by all the GSM operators, no doubt, generated a lot of issues of which poor quality of service is key as subscribers are expressing difficulties in getting calls through even with the bonus or without the bonus.
Johnson foresaw the ban:
The Communications Technology Minister, Mrs. Omobola Johnson, may have foresaw the ban, when she publicly lamented the rise in poor quality of service, which she attributed to numerous promos by operators which is increasing traffic on their networks.
So many industry watchers were not surprised when the telecommunications regulator came to town with the hammer, declaring a line of direction for all operators across board, be it GSM or CDMA and even for obviously ailing telcos.
Real reasons NCC banned promos
Apex telecommunications regulator in the land, the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) has adduced real reasons why it placed ‘blanket’ ban on all promotions and lotteries by seven telecom operators in the country.
The affected network operators consist of Globacom Limited, MTN Nigeria, Intercellular Nigeria plc, Visafone Communications Ltd, Etisalat Nigeria, Airtel Networks Limited and MultiLinks Telecoms Limited.
Director, Public Affairs at NCC, Mr. Tony Ojobo, explained in a three-point on why the ban on all promos has become imminent, describing the exercise by mobile operators as “abuse of market power.”
Protection of consumers, our interest …
According to him, the Commission has to take this step in order to protect and promote the interest of consumers against unfair practices, promote fair competition in the industry.
Additionally, he said, that NCC needed to protect telecom consumers from operators’ willingness to misuse market power, which are anti-competitive and unfair practices by operators.
Other reasons adduced by NCC for its action include “In due regard to the afore-mentioned responsibilities therefore and having observed that these promotions have increased the number of minutes available to subscribers for use within a limited period of time thereby creating congestion in the networks as subscribers try to use up the available minutes within the stipulated time. 
“That on-net calls were now being offered by operators at tariffs well below the prevailing inter-connect rates thereby introducing anti-competitive practices and behaviour, and;
“That termination of calls was becoming increasingly difficult from one network to another and overall consumer experience on the networks has become very poor thereby making it extremely difficult for subscribers to make calls successfully.
The big ban!
“Consequent upon the above-mentioned, the Commission therefore has banned all promotions by Telecommunications Network Operators as well as lotteries being carried out on such networks.  This ban covers all proposed and approved promotions and lotteries on which the Commission has given approval further to the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) entered into with the National Lottery Regulatory Commission (NLRC).”
NCC further observed that it has, in recent times been swamped with several complaints from consumers, industry stakeholders against the various promotions offered by telecommunications operators.
Reassuring consumers:
As said by him, the consistency of NCC motivated it to carefully evaluate the complaints received especially against the backdrop of sustaining the integrity of the networks, the general interest of the consumers, the socio-economic impact of these promotions on operators and other relevant stakeholders.
Just as NCC, he said, reassured all telecommunications consumers of its resolve to ensure that the Quality of Service (QoS) offered across all networks, as such that delivers value to the consumers.
Consumers’ React:
But for consumers the ban is different strokes for different people. While some hailed NCC for standing up to save the situation, others lamented their inability to gain free credits to talk to friends and families.
For the National Association of Telecommunications Subscribers (NATCOMS), it was an applause time for the federal government for putting an end to the sales promotions of telecom networks.
NATCOMS President, Chief Deolu Ogunbanjo said the stoppage would free-up the network which would also stop the current congestion on the networks.
“Telecom promotions have in one way or the other reduced tariffs across the networks and that has encouraged subscribers to enjoy talking freely,” Ogunbanjo noted. Adding that by putting a stop to the promos, Ogunbanjo strongly believes would compel telecom operators to upgrade their services.
“By this decision, telecom operators will want to expedite action to improve on their networks,” Ogunbanjo said that since that would be the only means to attract more subscribers.
ALTON reacts:
On the part of the operators who reacted through the chairman, Association of Licensed Telecoms Operators of Nigeria (ALTON), Mr. Gbenga Adebayo, pointed out that the issue of poor service quality being across networks of telephone operators goes beyond promotions and lotteries.
According to him, the major cause of poor service quality across networks should be attributed to natural and man-made disasters, rather than on promos and lotteries. These, he said, were caused by flooding in some southern parts of the country, while the man-made disasters were caused by spontaneous attacks on telecoms facilities in some northern parts of the country last September. He insisted that attacks on telecoms facilities last September and other incidences resulted in severe service disruptions in the areas primarily affected and by extension other parts of the country.
He said, the impact of the attacks had since limited the ability of millions of Nigerian subscribers to access telecommunications services, because the incidents affected over 250 telecoms sites that lost connection. Adebayo added that the unprecedented flood in some parts of the country destroyed Base Transceiver Stations (BTS) along its path, led to significant service disruption in the affected areas, with consequential impact on service availability in some other parts that were not affected by the flood.
Billions of telcom equipment lost to flood:
Apart from disruption of services, he said, ALTON members lost telecom equipment worth several billions of Naira to the flood disaster across the country, with some 300 BTS sites damaged by the flood.
For him, there is need to provide relevant protection to telecoms facilities in the national interest, stressing that the infrastructure built and owned by the telecommunications industry is the springboard to Information and Communications Technology (ICT) revolution in Nigeria, and thus deserve protection, because of their importance to socio-economic advancement of the Nigerian nation.
Way Forward:
The federal government could actually do something by looking at the entire quality of service issues differently, especially looking at the investment made by these operators and come up with some incentives, given the fact that recent flood disaster and attacks on over 300 Base Stations is not a chicken-change affair to get these base stations on again.
The earlier we release that these operators made investment, which desire sustainability efforts and return on investment, the better for us all.


Remmy Nweke, additional report Yinka Awosanya

... Making SENSE of digital revolution!

No comments: